Posted on

Dog Collars Vs Dog Harnesses

dog collar vs harness

The question of which tool is the best for dog training and dog walking is one that most people haven’t got a definite answer to. The two major options for this job are the dog collar and dog harness. Whether you and your dog need a dog collar or a dog harness depends on both the needs of the dog and those of yourself. This means that certain factors need to be considered in the process. There are four major factors to take into account when choosing the more appropriate of the two tools. The needs of the dog, the behaviours, attitudes of the dog and the benefits you want the dog to get are the four considerations here. Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of each:

Manoa Quock Vario Light Harness Blue

Dog Harness

Dog Harness Pros

All dog owners should know the health needs of their dogs before settling for the dog harness. The main benefits the harness has to offer include.

1. The harness is a great and very effective tool for training the dogs, especially if they are puppies. Also, certain breeds are more suited for the dog harness than others.

2. It’s able to discourage jumping and pulling by the dog. This way, they offer much better control of the dog. Hence, you will have more control over your dog’s actions, this not only allows you to stop your dog from pulling but because the harness spreads the weight more effectively, it means that your dog will not be injured as you keep your dog in range of yourself.

3. Distraction when taking your newly acquired puppy can become an issue, not only does this waste time you could be spending teaching your puppy a new trick but can also show the pup that they are in control. A non-pull dog harness or a non-pull puppy harness allows you to gently ‘nudge’ them in the right direction, this will encourage the puppy to continue the walk without displaying a forceful tug from a collar.

4. Dog’s like Pugs which have short noses are more suited for harnesses rather than the collars. This is because due to the windpipe being short, dogs like Pugs and English Bulldogs have less distinctive necks, which means that dog collars are less effective.

5. If your dog has problems like neck injuries and repository problems, this tool can be a more suitable choice for them because even the best collar for puppies and dogs will restrict the dog’s airflow as it surrounds the neck.

Dog Harness Cons

The major cons associated with dog harnesses include:

1. Most dogs may not be too happy with the feeling that they get when wearing the harnesses. This can become obvious if the dog has never worn a dog harness before. The best way to make your dog comfortable in a non-pull dog harness is to either train them from a young age to walk with a dog harness or to continue to use the dog harness until the dog feels more comfortable in it.

Note: Make sure that the dog harness is secure but not too tight, as it may feel as if your punishing the dog.

2. A type of harness like the back-clip harness may not be as effective as needed. This way, you’ll need to go for a front-clip harness instead because the former has been found to train the dog to ignore and pull their owners.

Freestyle Training Collar Red

Dog Collar

Dog Collar Pros

1. For puppies that like comfort and hate the feeling of a harness often this training tool very comfortable and suitable. The dog collar is also very light in comparison to the dog harness, so this makes wearing a dog collar feel less intrusive.

2. They’re great for functionality and visibility. In terms of convenience, they’re easier to slip on and off. They can hold tags such as rabies, identification and license, making them extremely handy.

Dog Collar Cons

The major drawbacks associated with dog collars include:

1. If you’re looking to train your puppy or dog, the collar isn’t the tool for you to get.

2. Neck injuries are very likely since there’s pressure that is directly applied to the neck of the dog or puppy. If pull too harshly this can lead to many health complications.

3. Other severe problems like thyroid issues due to damage to the gland, problems of behaviour as a result of injury and pain, eye and ear issues resulting from neck pressure could also be caused by the collar.


As we’ve noticed, there are both pros and cons associated with each of the tools. The choice, however, remains with you and your dog. Take into account all the necessary things before settling on either of these two.